
A storm knocks a limb onto your roof. A dead oak leans toward the power line. You grab your phone and start searching, and suddenly every company claims to be “fully insured” and “certified.” Some of them are telling the truth. Some are not. Choosing wrong means property damage, liability exposure, or a half-finished job. Here is how to separate legitimate tree care professionals from the rest.
Why Does Hiring the Wrong Tree Service Company Matter?
Tree work is one of the most dangerous trades in residential services. Chainsaws, heights, heavy limbs, and power lines create risks that do not exist in most home improvement projects. If an uninsured crew drops a limb on your neighbor’s car or a worker falls from your tree, the financial responsibility can land on you. The wrong company does not just do bad work. It transfers risk onto your property and your wallet.
What Credentials Should a Tree Service Company Have?
Look for ISA-certified arborists on staff and verify the certification before you hire. Ask for proof of liability insurance and workers’ compensation coverage. A legitimate company will provide certificates without hesitation.
ISA Certified Arborist
The International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) certification is the industry standard for tree care professionals. ISA Certified Arborists pass a comprehensive exam and must earn continuing education credits to maintain their credential. You can verify any arborist’s certification through ISA’s online directory by searching their name or certification number.
Certification does not guarantee quality, but it confirms the person has demonstrated knowledge of tree biology, pruning standards, and safe work practices. Membership in an arborist association is not the same as certification. Check the specific credential.
Liability Insurance
General liability insurance covers third-party property damage and injuries. If a limb destroys your fence or a worker damages your neighbor’s roof, this coverage pays the claim. Most tree care companies should carry at least $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate.
Ask for a certificate of insurance before work begins. Call the insurance company to confirm the policy is active. Fake certificates exist.
Workers’ Compensation Insurance
Workers’ compensation covers medical bills and lost wages if an employee gets hurt on your property. Most states require this coverage for businesses with employees. Tree work carries high injury rates, which makes this coverage essential. Without it, an injured worker could pursue you directly for medical costs.
How Do You Verify a Tree Service Company’s Credentials?
Verification takes five minutes and prevents expensive mistakes. Do not accept verbal assurances.
- ISA certification: Search the arborist’s name or certification number on the ISA directory.
- Liability insurance: Request the certificate of insurance and call the insurer to confirm.
- Workers’ compensation: Ask for the policy number and verify it with the state or the insurer.
- Business registration: Check with your state’s licensing board or secretary of state.
- Local references: Ask for addresses of recent jobs in your area and call those customers.
A company that hesitates or makes excuses about providing documentation is a company to avoid.
What Questions Should You Ask Before Hiring?
A short conversation tells you a lot. Legitimate companies answer directly. Scammers deflect.
About the Work
- Will you provide a written estimate with a detailed scope of work?
- Will you follow ANSI standards for pruning and removal?
- Do you use spikes for climbing? Spikes damage trees and should not be used on healthy trees being pruned.
- Who will actually perform the work, your employees or subcontractors?
- How will you protect my lawn, driveway, and landscaping?
About the Business
- How long have you been operating in this area?
- Can you provide three local references from similar jobs?
- What is your payment schedule?
- Do you offer a written contract?
About Cleanup and Follow-Up
- Will you remove all debris and grind the stump?
- What happens if the work does not meet the estimate?
- Do you offer any warranty on the work?
What Are the Warning Signs of a Problem Company?
Red flags are consistent across the industry. Any single one is a reason to walk away.
- Door-to-door solicitation: Legitimate companies do not usually sell tree work by knocking on doors after a storm.
- Demanding full payment upfront: A deposit is reasonable. Paying the entire job before work begins is not.
- No written estimate: Every job should have a written scope and price.
- Pressure tactics: “We can do it today only” is a sales tactic, not a scheduling reality.
- No physical address: A company that cannot provide a verifiable business address is not a company you want working on your property.
- Cash-only payment: Legitimate businesses invoice and accept traceable payment methods.
- Claims of insurance company affiliation: Companies claiming to be “working with your insurance” to get you a free removal are almost always running a scam.
- Topping trees: Topping is an injurious practice that damages trees permanently. Any company that advertises it does not understand tree biology.
What Should a Written Estimate Include?
A written estimate protects both parties. It should spell out exactly what will be done, what will be removed, and what it costs.
- Scope of work: Which trees, which limbs, which stumps.
- Equipment used: Crane, bucket truck, or climbing.
- Cleanup details: Debris removal, stump grinding, and disposal.
- Timeline: Start date and estimated completion.
- Payment schedule: Deposit amount and final payment terms.
- Insurance confirmation: Proof of liability and workers’ compensation.
- Price breakdown: Line-item pricing, not a single lump sum.
Get at least two or three written estimates before signing anything.
Why Homeowners Choose Godwin’s Tree Services
Godwin’s Tree Services handles tree removal, pruning, and stump grinding with ISA-certified arborists on staff and full liability and workers’ compensation coverage. We provide written estimates, verify our credentials on request, and leave the property clean. If you want a company that answers your questions directly and does the work right, reach out to schedule an assessment.
FAQs
Q1: How do I verify an ISA-certified arborist?
Visit ISA’s online directory at certificates.directory.isa-arbor.com and search by the arborist’s name or certification number. The portal confirms whether the credential is active and in good standing. Membership in an association is not the same as certification.
Q2: What insurance should a tree service company carry?
At minimum, general liability insurance and workers’ compensation coverage. General liability should be at least $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate. Workers’ compensation is legally required in most states for companies with employees. Always request certificates and verify them directly with the insurer.
Q3: How many estimates should I get for tree removal?
Get at least two or three written estimates. Compare the scope of work, not just the price. A low bid that excludes stump grinding or debris removal is not cheaper once you add those services back in. The cheapest estimate is rarely the best value.
Q4: How much does tree removal cost?
Most residential tree removals cost between $385 and $1,070, with a national average around $875. Large trees near power lines or structures run higher. Stump grinding, debris removal, and emergency work add to the total. Get a written estimate for your specific tree.
Q5: What are the biggest red flags when hiring a tree service company?
Door-to-door sales after a storm, demands for full payment upfront, no written estimate, no verifiable business address, and claims of insurance company affiliations are the biggest red flags. Any one of these is a reason to choose another company.